Serra Britt:
As you pull up, you see one tail... then two? Oh, it's a nekomata!
https://s1.postimg.org/6adjobiafj/nekomata2.png

Thank you ^_^

#10 Cold, flavorful.

ahhhh what a cute kitty!!

Number 5 sounds interesting!

Scythe:
On the end of the fishing line is what appears to be a strawberry slice cream... at least, I hope it's strawberry...
https://s1.postimg.org/9pby0gshvj/slicecream2.png

dragoness129:
Even though you pulled it from the pit, this nekomata refuses to stop batting at and playing with the fishing line.
https://s1.postimg.org/1mnz7of5z3/nekomata1.png

It is so adorable! Thanks, Isis!

*fiddles with the fish line and side-eyes number 9*

Very sorry, but #9 has already been drawn - the line is empty :s-dead:. I'll prob make more monsters tonight so there'll be more choices, so if you aren't interested in the available fishing poles there'll be more choices soon ^-^

Yay for more monsters!!

I was pretty good at fishing, except for sticking the worm on and taking the hook out. . . .
I grab -4. Woof woof woof, bright-

-Pulls up fishing pole #7. Boy, Orange- Hmmmmm....

SparX:
The fishing was a long battle, but you've finally reeled in your monster - a Cerberus whose colors seem to glow in the dark.
https://s1.postimg.org/5ms4lg77i7/cerebus2.png

Rainbowfox Ari:
What? This seems to be just an ordinary pumpkin... until it turns around, revealing its intelligent eyes. Oh, it's a pumpkin boy!
https://s1.postimg.org/9an71bky0f/pumpkinboy1.png

Sorry for taking so long :p-ugh:

I've also added more monsters to the first post, if anyone wants another monster. They're... interesting...

Derpy McBlueEyes:
Oh, looks like a little imp is hanging onto the line! He speaks from his turtle-like mouth, claiming to be very helpful, but I don't know if you should trust an imp...
https://s1.postimg.org/7tjlv7jpa7/imp.png

i just came here to say this is adorable and i lovee it