That's the idea, yes. You won't get a common for a rare, and vice-versa.

Ok, so I exchanged some monthly items, and I got special items back in return. O.o I thought I would be getting monthly item for monthly item. I'm kinda lost here.

No, there's no such limitation.

...Although, I could have sworn I had it disallow you from giving items bought with runes.


Okay. Now that I check the logs, you exchanged event items, not monthlies. That makes more sense. I didn't actually set up the exchange to limit items from Smooch Quest this time. I knew there was something I forgot...

...There aren't actually that many items from that, though. It's easy enough to get them all. :)

So the spoopiest exchange is NOT now the goopiest exchange?

I did exchange the game items, but I also exchanged a couple wysavra which is a monthly item.
It probably didn't go through, but I thought it did.

Goop just gums up the works, you know.