I got them just now but I'm not sure how different it is from the path of 'legs' only. Hmm. Gotta play more xD

I don't know if it's the same each time, but after playing through a couple of times what I got was...
No harm - never hunt - name - silent - disagree - silent = Legs
No harm - never hunt - name - silent - shrug - silent = Warm Legs.

As Gallah said, there is a bit of randomness. It just depends on the tier (bad, ok, well).

Followed your steps for the cave mdom and I got...hair XD
Probably some aspect of randomness here too.

I mean, I figured there was some randomness with it. Those were just the results I got those two with twice.

You a centipede?

Are you not?

Charlie's Hairclips is not on the list yet.
Idk how because I was aiming for Charlie, but messed up on one of the choices, so I randomly clicked to reach the end/restart asap. XD;;

maybe I'm dumb, but how do you get the items..??

You go to Games > Smooch Quest > Pick one you want to romance/get items from.
Or u can click here.

open the spoiler tag, some of the items have descriptions of the steps.
even though I'm told they don't work |D

mann I'm gonna work on those hairclips now xD

I have a feeling some of the items are a bit more random. I got Charlie's freckles 3 times so I thought there wasn't anything else, but there you go XD
I still have a few I need to get.

I just wanna be a doll myself, is that so bad?
UGH I can't get a leg or torso it seems XD

Sweet jesus, I just noticed Albert has a crop... I need to, em, play more smooch quest... *blushing*

EDIT: ffs, I've played through picking random options AND I STILL GOT THE DAMN ALBERT ITEM IDK IF THAT'S HELLA BAD OR HELLA GOOD LUCK