I don't know if I have/recognize which item it is...
(I wasn't expecting to get it right *turns red*)

Bah, don't blush. It was a really good guess. ^_^

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Lawtan
My Guess: 1

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Pessimistcat
My Guess: 3

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Espy
My Guess: 2

I am sorry Espy but that is not correct. Keep trying though!

Tiva that is not correct, but a good guess based on the last one Pessimistcat did.

That is not correct ml1201. Good guess though!

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Potrionette
My Guess: 1

...I feel like Galla's sitting out this one...

Unfortunately, that's incorrect Lawtan.

...Should I try again on #1?

You can if you want. ^_^

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Espy
My Guess: 1

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Lawtan
My Guess: 4

That is not correct Lawtan or Espy. Good guesses though.

What do you mean Galla?

...I think I know #3...

I Think I Know Who They Are!!
Username: Tiva
My Guess: 4